Write 3 Parts Criticism

hello

you are required to write a three-part referee report onan article assigned to you. As part of this referee report, you are expected to evaluate the papertowards potential publication in one of the premier journals in finance,

the Privateer Journalof Corporate Finance (https://www.elsevier.com/journals/journal-of-corporate-finance/0929-1199/guide-for-authors). Part 1 of the report should briefly summarize the paper’s importantcontributions in the best possible light. Part 2 should constructively critique the paper’simportant shortcomings. Part 3 should provide detailed guidelines for improvements. YourPage 3report should be accompanied by a very brief cover letter (addressed to me, the Journal Editor)indicating your recommendation about the paper — whether to reject, revise and resubmit, oraccept the article. Please also provide the reasons for your decision in the cover letter to theEditor. I will assign the article for the referee report in the third or fourth week of class. You can find the article Attachments and use the website to see if the article meet the requirement of the journal